Inspiration from the FAO - Keynote talks at the final SFN+ Conference
Caroline Wood
The 6th SFN+ Annual Conference held in 2024 was to be the last for the network in its current form, as STFC funding ends, but the organisers were determined to ‘go out with a bang’ and carry forward the legacy of SFN+ beyond the lifetime of the funding. To inspire the discussions, the SFN+ welcomed two distinguished speakers from The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations, who delivered plenty of food for thought.
Where we stand on Sustainable Development?
By Stefanos Fotiou, Director of the Office of Sustainable Development Goals and of the UN Food Systems Coordination Hub, FAO
The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, adopted by all United Nations (UN) members in 2015, created 17 world Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Although diverse, these are united in the ambition and valour of their aims – from zero hunger and no poverty, to action on climate and quality education for all. With 2024 putting us well over halfway towards the endpoint, where do we stand on achieving these?
“We are seeing very slow progress towards sustainable development with significant setbacks. For instance, 23 million more people were living in extreme poverty and over 123 million more suffering from hunger in 2022 compared to 2019.” Stefanos Fotiou
Unfortunately, the situation is not good: we are currently on track to meet only 15% of the SGDs, with over a third (36%) being stagnant or even in regression. For many goals, progress has been hindered by the COVID-19 pandemic, conflicts, and geopolitical and trade tensions. Worryingly, as Stefanos explained, the intensifying impacts of the climate and nature crises will make it even more challenging to make headway.
“Of the nine planetary boundaries we can assess, six have already been crossed. We are literally five minutes to midnight on a big environmental catastrophe” Stefanos said. “The other major ticking timebomb for sustainable development is rapidly escalating inequality within countries: the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer.”
With ‘business as usual’ clearly not an option, the focus of the UN’s 2023 SDG summit was to drive “a new phase of accelerated progress toward the SDGs with high-level political guidance on transformative and accelerated actions.” From this, the Secretary-General identified six key transitions for enabling the effective delivery of sustainable, resilient, and innovative high-impact solutions to reach the Goals by 2030. These were: social protection and decent jobs; transformed education systems; digital transformation; energy access and affordability; climate change, biodiversity loss and pollution; and food systems.”
“Of these, food systems was identified as the transition with the biggest potential to change progress” said Stefano. “Especially as it links so many of the SDGs together.” Achieving these will require a mix of both ‘engine room actions’ (such as a favourable financing landscape) and high-impact initiatives.
As Stefanos emphasised, the academic and education sector will play a big role in supporting all of these.
“The High-Level Political Forum 2025 will be a key opportunity to advance sustainable, inclusive, science- and evidence-based solutions for the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development” he said. “We will need innovative solutions from the academic community if we are to move the impacts of our actions from millions to billions and see that no one is left behind.”
The State of Food and Agriculture, 2024 - What’s Next?
Dr Andrea Cattaneo, Senior Economist for The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations.
Andrea began by presenting the findings from the FAO’s The State of Food and Agriculture (SOFA) 2024 report. This builds on the results of SOFA 2023 which revealed that global agrifood systems generate about 12 trillion USD in hidden costs – around 10% of global GDP. “SOFA 2024 provides a next step: an in-depth analysis to understand how we can reduce these costs and deliver better value from agrifood systems to benefit society” Andrea said.
The scope of the analysis, encompassing 150 countries, included environmental costs (such as GHG and nitrogen emissions, land-use change); health costs (unhealthy dietary patterns leading to noncommunicable diseases); and social costs (e.g. poverty, undernourishment). These were assessed right across the value chain – from primary production to retail, consumption and food waste.
“At the global level, we found that 70% of the hidden costs of the agrifood sector were associated with unhealthy dietary patterns, 25% with hidden environmental costs, and 5% with social costs” Andrea said. However, the burden of hidden costs varied substantially across agrifood system types. Traditional agrifood systems and those in ‘protracted crisis’ were disproportionately affected by hidden costs (when expressed relative to GDP), with industrial systems the least affected.
“Much of the environmental, social and health costs of our agrifood systems may be hidden, but someone is paying them – either directly or indirectly, today or in the future.” Dr Andrea Cattaneo
For the audience, this raised the question as to whether this result provided evidence in favour of shifting traditional farming systems to industrial ones. But Andrea was clear that, whilst industrial food systems can have some benefits (such as the ability to introduce certification schemes and increased access to products) they were not necessarily per se beneficial. “We should also bear in mind that in absolute monetary terms the health and environmental costs of food systems are much greater for high-income countries” he said. “However, because the economies of these countries are larger, when these are presented as the share of GDP, they don’t show up as strongly.”
With the health impacts taking the lion’s share, the analysis assessed these more deeply, breaking this down into 13 categories of factors that can drive unhealthy diets (such as low intake of whole grains, or high consumption of processed meat).
This found that globally, diets low in whole grains and fruits, but high in sodium are the leading dietary risks. However, this differed considerably across different agrifood systems and even countries. In India, for instance, the major dietary risk factors were found to be low intakes of nuts and seeds, fruits, and whole grains. Whereas in China, the main concern was excessive intakes of sodium.
This disparity makes it very clear that there can be no simple ‘one size fits all solution’ for addressing the imbalances. Instead, Andrea advocated that each country adopts a bespoke True Cost Accounting (TCA) approach that incorporates these hidden costs into decision making. But as the report’s case studies show, this comes with numerous challenges.
“For instance, hidden costs affect different actors disproportionately” Andrea said. “In Europe especially, primary producers often bear the burden of taking climate and environmental actions, but the beneficiaries of this are throughout the value chain.” He also notes that asymmetric power relations can hinder the fair distribution of costs and benefits, whilst regulatory, financial and market structures often favour maintaining the status quo.
Nevertheless, Andrea remained optimistic that there are mechanisms that could enable a just transition. “TCA enables informed decision-making and the identification of the best solutions. For instance, institutional procurement is an undervalued but effective way to start chipping away at the problems in a manner that is not too controversial, as demonstrated by the Good Food Purchasing initiative in New York State” he said.
Other tools include coordinated action in agrifood value chains, labelling and certification, public and private financing, and repurposing agricultural finance schemes to favour sustainable farming. Ultimately, bringing about the large-scale transformation of our agrifood chains that our planet needs will require each country to embrace a mix of the levers that SOFA 2024 outlines.
As Qu Dongyu, FAO Director-General, concluded in the report’s forward, “The journey ahead will be challenging, but the potential rewards are immense. By embracing the insights and recommendations of this report, we can build agrifood systems that nourish both people and the planet, today and for generations to come.”